Isolate containers with a user namespace

Estimated reading time: 10 minutes

Linux namespaces provide isolation for running processes, limiting their access to system resources without the running process being aware of the limitations. For more information on Linux namespaces, see Linux namespaces.

The best way to prevent privilege-escalation attacks from within a container is to configure your container’s applications to run as unprivileged users. For containers whose processes must run as the root user within the container, you can re-map this user to a less-privileged user on the Docker host. The mapped user is assigned a range of UIDs which function within the namespace as normal UIDs from 0 to 65536, but have no privileges on the host machine itself.

About remapping and subordinate user and group IDs

The remapping itself is handled by two files: /etc/subuid and /etc/subgid. Each file works the same, but one is concerned with the user ID range, and the other with the group ID range. Consider the following entry in /etc/subuid:

testuser:231072:65536

This means that testuser is assigned a subordinate user ID range of 230172 and the next 65536 integers in sequence. UID 231072 is mapped within the namespace (within the container, in this case) as UID 0 (root). UID 231073 is mapped as UID 1, and so forth. If a process attempts to escalate privilege outside of the namespace, the process is running as an unprivileged high-number UID on the host, which does not even map to a real user. This means the process has no privileges on the host system at all.

Multiple ranges

It is possible to assign multiple subordinate ranges for a given user or group by adding multiple non-overlapping mappings for the same user or group in the /etc/subuid or /etc/subgid file. In this case, Docker uses only the first five mappings, in accordance with the kernel’s limitation of only five entries in /proc/self/uid_map and /proc/self/gid_map.

When you configure Docker to use the userns-remap feature, you can optionally specify an existing user and/or group, or you can specify default. If you specify default, a user and group dockremap is created and used for this purpose.

Warning: Some distributions, such as RHEL and CentOS 7.3, do not automatically add the new group to the /etc/subuid and /etc/subgid files. You are responsible for editing these files and assigning non-overlapping ranges, in this case. This step is covered in Prerequisites.

It is very important that the ranges not overlap, so that a process cannot gain access in a different namespace. On most Linux distributions, system utilities manage the ranges for you when you add or remove users.

This re-mapping is transparent to the container, but introduces some configuration complexity in situations where the container needs access to resources on the Docker host, such as bind mounts into areas of the filesystem that the system user cannot write to. From a security standpoint, it is best to avoid these situations.

Prerequisites

  1. The subordinate UID and GID ranges must be associated with an existing user, even though the association is an implementation detail. The user will own the namespaced storage directories under /var/lib/docker/. If you don’t want to use an existing user, Docker can create one for you and use that. If you want to use an existing username or user ID, it must already exist. Typically, this means that the relevant entries need to be in /etc/password and /etc/group, but if you are using a different authentication back-end, this requirement may translate differently.

    To verify this, use the id command:

    $ id testuser
    
    uid=1001(testuser) gid=1001(testuser) groups=1001(testuser)
    
  2. The way the namespace remapping is handled on the host is using two files, /etc/subuid and /etc/subgid. These files are typically managed automatically when you add or remove users or groups, but on a few distributions such as RHEL and CentOS 7.3, you may need to manage these files manually.

    Each file contains three fields: the username or ID of the user, followed by a beginning UID or GID (which is treated as UID or GID 0 within the namespace) and a maxumum number of UIDs or GIDs available to the user. For instance, given the following entry:

    testuser:231072:65536
    

    This means that user-namespaced processes started by testuser will be owned by host UID 231072 (which will look like UID 0 inside the namespace) through 296608 (231072 + 65536). These ranges should not overlap, to ensure that namespaced processes cannot access each other’s namespaces.

    After adding your user, check /etc/subuid and /etc/subgid to see if your user has an entry in each. If not, you need to add it, being careful to avoid overlap.

    If you want to use the dockremap user automatically created by Docker, you’ll need to check for the dockremap entry in these files after configuring and restarting Docker.

  3. If there are any locations on the Docker host where the unprivileged user needs to write, adjust the permissions of those locations accordingly. This is also true if you want to use the dockremap user automatically created by Docker, but you won’t be able to modify the permissions until after configuring and restarting Docker.

  4. Enabling userns-remap will effectively mask existing image and container layers, as well as other Docker objects within /var/lib/docker/. This is because Docker needs to adjust the ownership of these resources and actually stores them in a subdirectory within /var/lib/docker/. It is best to enable this feature on a new Docker installation rather than an existing one.

    Along the same lines, if you disable userns-remap you will not see any of the resources created while it was enabled.

  5. Check the limitations on user namespaces to be sure your use case will be possible.

Enable userns-remap on the daemon

You can start dockerd with the --userns-remap flag or follow this procedure to configure the daemon using the daemon.json configuration file. The daemon.json method is recommended. If you use the flag, use the following command as a model:

$ dockerd --userns-remap="testuser:testuser"
  1. Edit /etc/docker/daemon.json. Assuming the file was previously empty, the following entry will enable userns-remap using user and group called testuser. You can address the user and group by ID or name. You only need to specify the group name or ID if it is different from the user name or ID. If you provide both the user and group name or ID, separate them by a colon (:) character. The following formats will all work for the value, assuming the UID and GID of testuser are 1001:

    • testuser
    • testuser:testuser
    • 1001
    • 1001:1001
    • testuser:1001
    • 1001:testuser
    {
      "userns-remap": "testuser"
    }
    

    Note: To use the dockremap user and have Docker create it for you, set the value to default rather than testuser.

    Save the file and restart Docker.

  2. If you are using the dockremap user, verify that Docker created it using the id command.

    $ id dockremap
    
    uid=112(dockremap) gid=116(dockremap) groups=116(dockremap)
    

    Verify that the entry has been added to /etc/subuid and /etc/subgid:

    $ grep dockremap /etc/subuid
    
    dockremap:231072:65536
    
    $ grep dockremap /etc/subgid
    
    dockremap:231072:65536
    

    If these entries are not present, edit the files as the root user and assign a starting UID and GID that is the highest-assigned one plus the offset (in this case, 65536). Be careful not to allow any overlap in the ranges.

  3. Verify that previous images are not available using the docker image ls command. The output should be empty.

  4. Start a container from the hello-world image.

    $ docker run hello-world
    
  5. Verify that a namespaced directory exists within /var/lib/docker/ named with the UID and GID of the namespaced user, owned by that UID and GID, and not group-or-world-readable. Some of the subdirectories are still owned by root and have different permissions.

    $ sudo ls -ld /var/lib/docker/231072.231072/
    
    drwx------ 11 231072 231072 11 Jun 21 21:19 /var/lib/docker/231072.231072/
    
    $ sudo ls -l /var/lib/docker/231072.231072/
    
    total 14
    drwx------ 5 231072 231072 5 Jun 21 21:19 aufs
    drwx------ 3 231072 231072 3 Jun 21 21:21 containers
    drwx------ 3 root   root   3 Jun 21 21:19 image
    drwxr-x--- 3 root   root   3 Jun 21 21:19 network
    drwx------ 4 root   root   4 Jun 21 21:19 plugins
    drwx------ 2 root   root   2 Jun 21 21:19 swarm
    drwx------ 2 231072 231072 2 Jun 21 21:21 tmp
    drwx------ 2 root   root   2 Jun 21 21:19 trust
    drwx------ 2 231072 231072 3 Jun 21 21:19 volumes
    

    Your directory listing may have some differences, especially if you user a different container storage driver than aufs.

    The directories which are owned by the remapped user are used instead of the same directories directly beneath /var/lib/docker/ and the unused versions (such as /var/lib/docker/tmp/ in the example here) can be removed. Docker will not use them while userns-remap is enabled.

Disable namespace remapping for a container

If you enable user namespaces on the daemon, all containers are started with user namespaces enabled by default. In some situations, such as privileged containers, you may need to disable user namespaces for a specific container. See user namespace known limitations for some of these limitations.

To disable user namespaces for a specific container, add the --userns=host flag to the docker create, docker run, or docker exec command.

User namespace known limitations

The following standard Docker features are incompatible with running a Docker daemon with user namespaces enabled:

  • sharing PID or NET namespaces with the host (--pid=host or --network=host).
  • A --read-only container filesystem. This is a Linux kernel restriction against remounting an already-mounted filesystem with modified flags when inside a user namespace.
  • external (volume or storage) drivers which are unaware or incapable of using daemon user mappings.
  • Using the --privileged mode flag on docker run without also specifying --userns=host.

User namespaces are an advanced feature and require coordination with other capabilities. For example, if volumes are mounted from the host, file ownership must be pre-arranged need read or write access to the volume contents.

While the root user inside a user-namespaced container process has many of the expected privileges of the superuser within the container, the Linux kernel imposes restrictions based on internal knowledge that this is a user-namespaced process. One notable restriction is the inability to use the mknod command. Permission will be denied for device creation within the container when run by the root user.

security, namespaces